Goosebump by Goosebump, is a distillation of lessons learned and personal growth from two years of the band working on material and touring across North America. Along the way, some changes have occurred: keyboardist Kirsten Dahlin Nolan bowed out after finishing the record. They decided their band name was bad. They started and stopped recording sessions until they felt they’d landed on the right thing, eventually rolling tape with Chris Shannon and Nathan Vanderwielen at Sonology, and later mixing with Adrian Mottram.
If the last record gave voice to the band’s nascent aspirations, Goosebump by Goosebump showcases a hard-won sense of accomplishment and identity. Never before have Erlichman and Rankin shown such a clear sense of their songwriting strengths and how to mobilize them, resulting in a record that moves excitedly from one idea to the next, full-hearted and effusive in its sophisticated pop enthusiasm.
Doubling down on the two-sides-of-a-coin approach, Goosebump splits Paul and Neil’s songs down the middle (there’s a “Side P” and a “Side N”) , highlighting both their individual growth as songwriters, and the way they’ve grown closer together as collaborators. Far from being twin silos, the real power of the songs comes from the way everyone pitches in on the details.
Drummer Mike Duffield’s contribution to the final arrangements are crucial, both in terms of his rock solid timekeeping and his gift for understated flourishes. Ruhee Dewji (sax), Kristina Koski (flute), and Lee Rose (violin) also add their voices, and it’s this open trust and collective attention to the seamwork that elevates the songs beyond pop proficiency into something special, a record that defines itself on its own terms while being in dialogue with the world around it.
In a way, Goosebump is a culmination of all that’s come before it, but it feels more like a debut record. From the exquisite chorus-drenched guitars and fully-inside-the-pocket rhythm section, to the lilting violin drones, subtly pitch-shifted piano keys and No-Jacket-Required roto-tom accents, Goosebump by Goosebump is both explosive and elegant, a welcome salutation from a band who’s never known more about who they are and what they’re good at.